Mooroobool carer Terrance Barallon was given a life sentence for murdering disability pensioner Robert Duffy in 2017.
Mooroobool carer Terrance Barallon was given a life sentence for murdering disability pensioner Robert Duffy in 2017.

Questions raised in disabled pensioner’s grisly murder case

The killer of a disabled pensioner, whose body was found bound with twine and gagged, has asked Queensland’s highest court to overturn his conviction.

Terrence Steven Arthur Barallon was given a life sentence for the brutal murder of Robert Duffy at his Mooroobool home on February 17, 2017.

The 62-year-old’s body was found days after his death with a stereo cord wrapped around his feet, his hands bound with an ironing cord and a belt pulled tightly around his neck.

Yellow twine had also been wrapped around his neck, legs and torso.

Carer pleads not guilty to murder over ‘brutal death’ of disabled pensioner

Alleged murderer claims he was on holiday in Port Douglas

Mr Duffy had a fractured skull, neck compression, crushed ribs and a blocked airway – likely from tissue paper that was lodged in his throat.

Terrance Barallon pleaded guilty to manslaughter but was found guilty of murder.
Terrance Barallon pleaded guilty to manslaughter but was found guilty of murder.

Barallon – Mr Duffy’s live-in carer – admitted to manslaughter in Cairns Supreme Court, but was ultimately convicted of murder by a jury.

At the Queensland Court of Appeal on Thursday, Barallon’s defence team argued that his conviction should be downgraded to manslaughter.

Barrister Andrew Hoare, who took on Barallon’s case pro bono, argued that there was not enough evidence to suggest the killing was intentional.

Robert Duffy, whose body was found bound and gagged on the ensuite floor, of his Dodd St home.
Robert Duffy, whose body was found bound and gagged on the ensuite floor, of his Dodd St home.

He said Barallon claimed he had “flipped out” after Mr Duffy sexually assaulted him, sending Barallon into a “blind rage”.

“It must be submitted that it was unreasonable for the jury to find he wasn’t provoked,” Mr Hoare said.

The court was told that Mr Duffy had significant heart issues.

Mr Hoare suggested that some of Mr Duffy’s injuries, and the binding to his hands, could have been inflicted after his death.

But Crown prosecutor Philip McCarthy QC said treating the killing as a “thoughtless reactive attack” overlooked the degree of force used and number of injuries Mr Duffy suffered.

Mr McCarthy said the bruising on Mr Duffy’s wrists made it “highly unlikely” that he was dead when being tied up, because bruising required blood flow.

During the trial, the jury was also told that Mr Duffy had defensive wounds which suggested he was bound while still alive.

The Court of Appeal reserved its decision to a later date.

Originally published as Questions raised in disabled pensioner’s grisly murder case



Driver suffers injuries after car smashes into tree

Premium Content Driver suffers injuries after car smashes into tree

Paramedics rushed to Peregian Springs on Tuesday night after a driver crashed into...

Gympie Magistrates Court appearances for today

Premium Content Gympie Magistrates Court appearances for today

Here is a list of matters listed at Gympie Magistrates Court

More severe storms on the way

Premium Content More severe storms on the way

More wild weather on the way after severe storms batter southeast