News

Coroner faults builders, welders, engineers and surveyors

CHATSWORTH father Steve Raabe has finally achieved all the justice he can for his son Craig, killed in 2007, when Category 5 Cyclone George tore across the West Australian coastline.

A coroner has now found that human incompetence, to a point that "beggars belief", was what killed Craig Raabe, and not just the most destructive cyclone to hit the Pilbara in more than 30 years.

Coroner Ros Fogliani blamed inattention by almost everyone associated with the building, planning and approval of buildings which had been built to the wrong specifications and had no chance of withstanding the storm.

"This inquest highlighted the danger to public safety when construction compliance fails and gives way to expediency," she said.

Ms Fogliani ruled that Debra Till and Craig Raabe would have survived the cyclone if not for repeated errors by the people who designed, built and approved their dongas on the Fortescue Metals rail camp where they worked.

The dongas were built to an inadequate and mistakenly applied wind rating and suffered from structural deficiencies.

"These arose by reason of a series of errors made by persons who had the knowledge and/or means to avoid them, had they applied proper standards of care and attention to the task at hand."

Coroner Ros Fogliani found that shelter provided for Craig Raabe and his fellow victim Debra Till was fatally inadequate, due to the inadequate performance of builders, welders, engineers and surveyors in charge of camp construction.

An earlier inquest had found that the camp was built to the wrong wind rating - a standard which prescribes the strength of wind buildings must be able to withstand.

The temporary accommodation had no chance of withstanding the storm, she ruled.

Mr Raabe was an excavator operator at the camp and Ms Till was a kitchen hand at the camp, which housed employees working on Fortescue's remote rail line between the Cloudbreak mine and Port Hedland.

Cyclone George blew away Ms Till's donga, killing her instantly.

Mr Raabe's donga flipped on to its roof and Mr Raabe died in hospital from head injuries.

"It beggars belief," Ms Fogliani found, "that persons responsible for the design, building and licence approval kept making, essentially the same error regarding the wind region.

"The result was that dongas designed and constructed for a non-cyclonic wind region were built in a cyclonic wind region.

"Shortly after they were completed, a number were destroyed by Cyclone George."

She criticised local government approval processes and the application of wind rating rules, as well as building procedures.

"The fatal injuries suffered by Ms Till and Mr Raabe as a consequence of their dongas being destroyed were preventable," she said.

Mr Steve Raabe said the mine owner was cleared of any wrongdoing and mines were found to be exempt from the OHS Act.

Gympie Times

Topics:  coastline coroner



Six hideaway bars to escape winter chill

THE last season of GoT finally uttered the words we’ve been waiting six seasons to hear and now that the weather has cooled down in Brisbane, “winter is here.”

Our six art gallery picks for a creative day out

Queensland's Gallery of Modern Art always has a fun, exciting and interesting exhibition on show for the whole family to enjoy.

YOU'D be mistaken in thinking Brisbane wasn't an arty city.

Brisbane's arts and culture events centre stage

You loved the film, now you're about to love the musical. Don't miss The Bodyguard The Musical in Brisbane this July.

THE arts and culture events you don't want to miss.

Homewares stores to fulfil your Instagram dreams

No Caption

You too can become an Insta-star with these fab stores.

Date nights under $50

Nothing is more romantic than a picnic with a cracking view.

NOT every date has to cost you a bomb.

Top 10 Brisbane experiences to cross off your bucket list

Do yourself a favour and get amongst the food truck scene. Eat Street is a great place to start.

A GOOD bucket list doesn’t have to span continents or cost millions.

Six mega sporting events you need to be at this year

Don't miss all the action trackside this season.

IF THERE is one thing Brisbane does damn well, it’s play host.

'Black dog' police deaths spark call for memorial

Retired Sunshine Coast police officer Ian Browne supports a push to have officers who take their own lives included on state and national memorials.

'We should honour them': Push for memorials gains momentum

Gympie's Caitlyn Shadbolt releases debut album in concert

Caitlyn Shadbolt has launched her debut album in a concert at the Gympie Civic Centre on Sunday afternoon.

Shadbolt releases debut album in Gympie concert

All the rodeo results from the Gympie Show

Gympie Show Rodeo - Hayley Millard U/18 Junior Barrel Race

Did you or someone you know enter the Gympie Show?

Local Partners

Big Pineapple festival safety concerns as 100s walk home

WOOMBYE'S Big Pineapple festival brought in the crowds, and the traffic.

Shot at the live shows slips through Sally's fingers

Sally Skelton and Bojesse Pigram pictured after their battle performance on The Voice.

Sunshine Coast singer's dramatic elimination from The Voice

Ben Stiller and Christine Taylor split after 17 years

They were married in May 2000 and have two children, who they said will remain their priority.

Ben Stiller and his wife Christine Taylor have called it a day

Why The Voice hasn't produced a star

Boy George responds to Brittania Clifford-Pugh's heart-warming message.

It's the industry, not the show, says Boy George

These actors hated their movies and didn’t mind admitting it

Channing Tatum and Marlon Wayans in a scene from GI Joe: The Rise of Cobra.

Every year, Hollywood blesses us with plenty of God awful movies.

Miranda Kerr and fiance hang up backyard tent for wedding

The decorators and caterers are arriving for the final preparations for the wedding of Miranda Kerr and Evan Spiegel. Pictures: Splash

Evan Spiegel and Miranda Kerr are set to marry today

Book review: Mia Freedman's book meets her critics head on

I appreciated Freedman's blunt honesty in the book

This is real estate's billion-dollar man

Bob Wolff at AREC with John McGrath of McGrath Real Estate.

They don’t call him the “Billion dollar man” for nothing

Man's amazing comeback from monster crisis

Pat O'Driscoll agents Penny Keating and Doug Webber sold 56 Agnes St, The Range at auction over the weekend.

NOT long ago, he sold his possessions to pay staff. Now he's back.

Report reveals progress on $319m airport upgrade

Aerials of the Sunshine Coast.Jetstar plane in front of the Susnhine Coast terminal, Sunshine Coast Airport.

Over two dozen government approvals needed for airport expansion

Lost dough leaves sour taste after company collapse

Kathleen and John Mahoney from Sugar and Spice Bakery were stung after the collapse of Cantro Pty Ltd and are still owed money.

Supermarket operator collapse leaves sour taste for bakery

Open for inspection homes May 25-31

Check out this weekend's homes open for inspection

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!