Chantal Barnett and Robert Martinez went missing in March 2013. Two men accused of their murders have had their trial aborted this morning in the Supreme Court.
Chantal Barnett and Robert Martinez went missing in March 2013. Two men accused of their murders have had their trial aborted this morning in the Supreme Court.

Double murder trial aborted for 'highly unlikely' issue

A MURDER trial over the deaths of Robert Martinez and Chantal Barnett has been aborted on the second day.

The trial of Ian Robert Armstrong and Daniel George Hong had only sat for one day before it was revealed that two jury members had a connection to one of the people involved in the trial, unbeknown to them.

Justice Graeme Crow said the issue was bought to light this morning and the options were to dismiss just the two jury members and run the trial, leaving a risk of other jurors being dismissed at a later stage and leaving a panel of 11.

The court heard one of the defence barristers would "resist a verdict of only 11 jurors".

"The predicted highly unlikely consequence of two related persons out of a panel of over a hundred actually being selected upon an extended jury of 14 is very low," Justice Crow said.

"This was not anticipated.

"In balancing the risks it is my view that it is proper to discharge the entire jury and to recommence the trial at 10am tomorrow."

The jury had heard the opening addresses from crown prosecutor Vicki Loury, Mr Hong's defence barrister Stephen Kissick and Mr Armstrong's defence barrister Andrew Hoare.

They had also heard evidence from six of the 80 witnesses.

The court heard today the trial is now expected to take two weeks rather than the four original set.



5 things under debate at next council meeting

premium_icon 5 things under debate at next council meeting

State forces Gympie council to take closer look at future of $400 million asset

Alcohol sales plummet post-panic buying

premium_icon Alcohol sales plummet post-panic buying

Aussie liquor producers suffer through worst month on record.

COVID-19 claims another Gympie event victim

premium_icon COVID-19 claims another Gympie event victim

Yet another Gympie event has had to be cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic